Dear Editor,
I just finished reading "Instability in the Neighborhood: Modi’s Impact on the Soul of India" and felt compelled to share my thoughts. The article raises some crucial points about Modi's third term and its implications.
It’s clear that Modi’s continued rule is stirring up significant concerns. The article makes a strong case about the way Modi’s policies have been shifting India’s democratic and secular values, particularly with the rise of Hindutva nationalism. I was especially struck by the idea that Modi’s leadership is pushing India towards a more centralized, majoritarian state, sidelining the country’s rich diversity.
One of the most interesting aspects is the discussion about how Modi's third term, despite not being an overwhelming victory, still means his influence is strong. The fact that the BJP had to rely on allies this time around might indicate some cracks in the facade, as the article suggests. Yet, Modi's ability to maintain power despite these setbacks shows just how deep his political grip is.
It’s also eye-opening to see the emphasis on the increasing violence and legislation targeting minorities under Modi’s rule. The article makes a compelling argument about how his populist rhetoric has real-world consequences for India’s minorities, particularly Muslims.
I agree with the article’s concern about how Modi’s style of governance might continue to affect India’s internal stability and its international relationships. It’s a tough spot for India, balancing domestic issues with a growing geopolitical role.
Let’s hope that the increasing scrutiny and the presence of a stronger opposition might lead to some changes. India’s democracy and secularism are too important to be compromised.

Best regards,  
Ali Raza, Lahore
August 7, 2024